Skip to main content

The Market Validation Process

Welcome to Basilio Inc. The Market Validation Process. If you’re thinking about starting up your own business as an Amazon seller, stick around, because you’ve come to the right place. 

In this comprehensive guide,  you’ll uncover the power of market validation through insightful competitor analysis. Our data-driven approach enables informed decisions when launching product lines on Amazon, helping us understand our strengths and weaknesses for a proficient market entry. By focusing on delivering value to the marketplace, our strategies can benefit your business too. This book provides comprehensive insights and data-driven strategies to identify and compete effectively against worthy opponents, optimizing your efforts for maximum impact

Chapter 6 – The Buy Box Scenarios

When conducting a competitor analysis on Amazon listings, understanding the significance of the Buy Box and its components can yield valuable insights into the competitive landscape. The Buy Box is a critical element prominently displayed on the product page, allowing customers to add items instantly to their cart.

Suppressed Buy Boxes:

A suppressed Buy Box, also known as a rolled or collapsed Buy Box, serves as Amazon’s penalty for pricing inconsistencies among sellers. Amazon prioritizes showcasing products with the best prices and fastest shipping to enhance the shopping experience. If pricing varies significantly across sellers or platforms, Amazon may suppress the Buy Box for those listings.

Off-Amazon Competition Impact:

Amazon acknowledges that the same products are available on other platforms like Walmart, Target, and Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) sites. To avoid losing sales to lower-priced competitors on these marketplaces, Amazon rolls the Buy Box when it detects pricing discrepancies. This can lead shoppers to encounter a suppressed Buy Box, potentially prompting them to seek alternative options.

Leveraging Suppressed Buy Boxes:

A suppressed Buy Box doesn’t make a product unavailable for purchase, but it can cause shoppers to explore other choices. If you notice a competitor’s listing with a rolled Buy Box, it presents an opportunity to capture traffic seeking better options. By ensuring your pricing aligns with Amazon’s guidelines, you can attract customers who might have turned away from competitors’ listings with subpar Buy Boxes.

Important Consideration:

To make competitive pricing effective, it’s crucial to match the current sale price with off-Amazon pricing. For instance, if you lower your product’s price on your DTC site by $3, you must adjust the current sale price on Amazon accordingly. It’s worth noting that price reductions through coupons or shipping cost adjustments do not count as factors for competitive pricing on Amazon.

The Buy Box Scenarios

When navigating the competitive Amazon landscape, you’ll inevitably encounter numerous sellers vying for the same product spotlight, making it crucial to assess your competition within the Buy Box. The Buy Box is a coveted spot that indicates how many sellers offer a particular product, and a higher number of sellers signifies a popular and sought-after product.

  • Counting Sellers in the Standard Buy Box: Just below the Buy Box section, you’ll find indicators like “New (#)” or “New and Used (#).” Click on this section to reveal the number of sellers on the listing and their Buy Box information.
  • Unveiling Rolled Buy Box Sellers: Click “See All Buying Options” within the Buy Box to access a comprehensive list of all sellers and their Buy Box details, providing valuable insights into your competition.

Beyond the quantity of sellers, another critical aspect to consider is analyzing their stock levels. While Amazon won’t disclose exact stock levels, you can utilize certain paid tools to obtain estimates. Take note of the following points:

  • Impact of Stock Levels: Low stock levels may indicate a potential risk of going out of stock, which can impact your listing’s rank on the search engine results page (SERP). On the other hand, high stock levels suggest fierce competition for an extended period.
  • Evaluate Stock Adequacy: Assess your monthly sales volume and compare it with the seller’s stock levels. If their stock can last a month, they are competitively stocked. However, if their stock may not suffice for a month, they may face stock-outs, affecting their visibility on the SERP.

Fulfillment Type Matters

The choice between Fulfilled by Merchant (FBM) and Fulfilled by Amazon (FBA) significantly impacts your Amazon selling success. FBM involves shipping products directly from a non-Amazon warehouse, but it often results in longer shipping times and higher shipping costs, leading to lower favorability in Amazon’s algorithm. In contrast, FBA sellers benefit from faster shipping, Prime eligibility, and a competitive edge. For FBM sellers to stay competitive, achieving Seller Fulfilled Prime status by showcasing efficient shipping speeds becomes crucial.

Competing with Amazon Retail

Facing competition from Amazon Retail can be daunting for sellers as Amazon often dominates this segment. It’s essential to assess the viability of direct competition with Amazon Retail and explore alternative segments that may offer better opportunities for success. Identifying unique selling points and targeting specific customer niches can help in differentiating from Amazon Retail.

Strategic Pricing for Winning the Buy Box

Pricing plays a pivotal role in securing the coveted buy box and attracting customers. While offering the lowest price can be beneficial, it’s not the sole determinant for buyers. Customers also consider overall value, product reviews, features, and brand reputation. Aligning pricing decisions with costs, margins, and perceived value compared to competitors can be a winning strategy. Emphasizing unique value propositions through compelling product descriptions and A+ Content can justify higher prices and attract value-conscious buyers.

Managing Shipping Windows and Inventory

Maintaining a positive customer experience requires effective management of shipping windows and inventory. If you anticipate inventory delays leading to longer shipping times, consider participating in programs like the In-Stock Head Start Program, providing customers with estimated shipping dates to make informed buying decisions. Transparency and efficient inventory management are key to building customer trust and loyalty.

Data from Customer Reviews
The reviews and ratings section on Amazon presents an unrivaled opportunity to gain valuable insights into your competitors’ performance and customers’ opinions.

Product’s Strengths:

Customer reviews allows you to identify how shoppers refer to your competitors’ products and the various names they associate with them. Embracing these variations and optimizing your listing with all applicable terms enables you to reach a broader audience and enhance visibility.

Favorite Features:

Customers enthusiastically express their favorite features of competitors’ products in reviews. These insights reveal what resonates with your target audience and what they value most. By integrating these prized features into your listing, you can showcase them prominently to attract potential buyers and stand out from the competition.

Pain Points:

Reviews vividly expose areas where your competitors fall short. Customers openly share details of their dissatisfaction, outlining potential pain points. By addressing these shortcomings in your product’s description and clarifying how your offering overcomes them, you can effectively position your product as a superior choice.

Learning from Mistakes:

Reviews offer invaluable lessons from your competitors’ mistakes. Understanding where they have disappointed customers provides you with the opportunity to proactively address similar concerns in your own offering. By maintaining transparency and addressing issues highlighted in competitor reviews, you can build trust and credibility with your customers.

Meet the Author

CEO, Founder

Jerome Basilio